NAS Afghanistan v. Afghanistan Civil Aviation Authority and others
ICC · Investment (ICSID and treaty) · Afghanistan · 16 Dec 2022
Why it matters
This ICC award is significant for its detailed analysis of contractual exclusivity rights in the aviation ground handling sector in Afghanistan. It addresses the interplay between a basic agreement and a joint venture agreement, and the consequences of unlawful termination. The award also clarifies the tribunal's jurisdiction over state entities and the application of Afghan investment law. It provides guidance on damages calculation for lost profits and management fees, and the treatment of performance guarantees.
Summary
NAS Afghanistan (formerly NAS Kuwait) entered into a Basic Agreement and Joint Venture Partnership Agreement (JVPA) with Ariana Afghan Airlines, the Afghanistan Civil Aviation Authority (ACAA), and the Ministry of Transportation to provide ground handling services at three Afghan airports. The agreements granted NAS Afghanistan exclusive rights to provide these services. In October 2020, Respondents terminated the JVPA, alleging illegality and material breach, and took over NAS Afghanistan's equipment and operations. They also cashed a USD 1 million performance guarantee. NAS Afghanistan initiated ICC arbitration under the Basic Agreement's arbitration clause, seeking damages for breach of contract. The tribunal, seated in London, found that it had jurisdiction over NAS Afghanistan's claims but not over NAS Kuwait, which had assigned its rights. On liability, the tribunal held that Respondents breached the agreements by failing to enforce exclusivity rights, unlawfully terminating the JVPA, and failing to return equipment. The tribunal rejected Respondents' illegality and material breach defenses. On quantum, the tribunal awarded USD 6,942,155 for failure to return equipment, USD 10,416,050 for breach of exclusivity rights, and USD 8,846,865 for lost profits and management fees from the unlawful termination, totaling USD 26,205,070. It also ordered payment of ICC arbitration costs and legal fees, with interest at LIBOR + 2% simple. The award is final and binding.
The detail
Parties: NAS Afghanistan v. Afghanistan Civil Aviation Authority and others
Case number: ICC Case No. 25820/AYZ/ELU
Outcome: Claimant NAS Afghanistan awarded damages for breach of contract; Respondents ordered to pay USD 26,205,070 plus interest and costs.
Quantum: USD 26,205,070
Applicable law: ICC Rules 2012; Basic Agreement dated 10 Dec 2013; Joint Venture Partnership Agreement dated 4 Nov 2013; Afghanistan Private Investment Law 2005.
Issues in play: Contractual interpretation of exclusivity rights and termination clauses under Afghan law; interaction between the Basic Agreement and the Joint Venture Partnership Agreement.
Read the full decision at italaw ↗
Locus Standi links to the source decision and publishes its own plain-language summary. It does not reproduce the text of the award.