CAS 2024 A 10701
CAS · Football (FIFA / CAS) · Switzerland · 14 Feb 2025
Why it matters
This award clarifies the standard for imposing provisional sanctions under the FIFA Code of Ethics, particularly the two alternative limbs of Article 86(1): interference with investigations or prima facie breach when a merits decision cannot be taken early enough. It also addresses procedural fairness in expedited ethics proceedings, confirming that de novo review by CAS can cure procedural violations at the first-instance level.
Summary
Bassam Adeel Jaleel, former President of the Football Association of Maldives (FAM), appealed a FIFA Ethics Committee decision to provisionally suspend him for 9 months. The suspension was based on allegations that Jaleel misused FIFA funds, including transferring USD 10,000 from a FIFA Forward account to his personal account, using USD 1 million from FIFA Covid Relief Funds to settle personal debts, misusing USD 1,036,000 meant for a construction project, and unilaterally modifying the project without FIFA approval. The FIFA Ethics Committee's Adjudicatory Chamber (AC) imposed the provisional sanction under Article 86 FCE, finding that Jaleel's continued involvement could interfere with the investigation and that a prima facie breach existed. Jaleel argued procedural violations, including insufficient time to respond and lack of specification of the sanction sought. The CAS Panel conducted a de novo review, finding that while Jaleel's right to be heard was partially violated (e.g., denial of extension), these were cured by CAS's full review. The Panel confirmed that the AC Chairperson was competent, and that the conditions for provisional sanctions were met under both limbs of Article 86(1): interference with investigations (due to Jaleel's access to bank accounts and potential to influence witnesses) and prima facie breach (based on evidence of fund misuse). The 9-month ban was deemed proportionate, balancing FIFA's interest in integrity against Jaleel's limited prejudice. The appeal was dismissed, and the suspension upheld.
The detail
Parties: Bassam Adeel Jaleel v. FIFA
Case number: CAS 2024 A 10701
Outcome: Appeal dismissed; FIFA's decision to provisionally suspend Jaleel for 9 months confirmed.
Applicable law: FIFA Code of Ethics (FCE), particularly Articles 86 (provisional sanctions), 20 (conflict of interest), 21 (gifts), 26 (abuse of position), 29 (misappropriation); CAS Code of Sports-related Arbitration
Issues in play: The case involved balancing FIFA's interest in protecting football's integrity against Jaleel's personality rights, applying the standard of 'comfortable satisfaction' for prima facie breaches under Article 86 FCE.
Read the full decision at Court of Arbitration for Sport (football, via FIFA) ↗
Locus Standi links to the source decision and publishes its own plain-language summary. It does not reproduce the text of the award.